Big Announcement!

HeirShares has partnered with the American Forest Foundation (AFF) to help families understand their land ownership, resolve title issues, and connect with reliable legal support.

This partnership aims to help families protect their land and generate income through the AFF Family Forest Carbon Program (FFCP). Watch the video below to learn more and visit our program page for additional information.

A Note from Mavis

Recently, I sat on a panel at the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta on the future of a recently released guide titled Ethical Engagement in Heirs' Property Work. Around the room were fellow attorneys, scholars, funders, and more. And we celebrated the fact that, for the first time, our field has a formal framework to help us navigate working with families who own real estate across multiple generations, particularly heirs' property owners.

I am, though, grappling with what these guidelines mean in the "wild". There are a multitude of ethical frameworks at play when it comes to real estate, even for a single parcel. In my work, family homes are always affected by the application of various ethical frameworks by the parties involved.

Thankfully, Dick Wolf creates wonderfully dramatic shows that I love because I can always find an angle on my work. For example, the Chicago PD scene I recently saw that resonates with me on the topic of ethics and family-owned real estate. Below, I detail the scene and a real-life example of how.

First, let’s discuss words.

Luther Vandross said a house is not a home. So let’s be clear what the term “home” implies: for the families, the parcels are "home." For law enforcement, the local tax authority, a realtor likely working with a developer, the local court, the planning office, housing agencies, and the developers themselves, the two parcels mean so many other things.

Thankfully, a scene from Chicago PD is helping me think through this collision of meanings. Join me?

Words of the Week

Ethics: The set of principles or values that govern the behavior of an individual or group.

Example: In the Chicago PD scene, the mother’s ethics are relational—rooted in protecting her family. The officers’ ethics are utilitarian—they believe breaking one family is a fair price to pay to stop a city-wide gang war.

Ethical Framework: A structured set of rules or guidelines used to determine right or wrong in a specific professional context.

Example: For many, gentrification is framed as an "economic" framework of progress. But for a land-rich, cash-poor family, it is a "displacement" framework—one where progress looks like erasure.

The Interrogation: Chicago PD (S1, E9: “A Material Witness”)

In this episode, Sgt. Voight (the "not bad meaning bad, but bad meaning good" veteran) and Detective Sumner (the outsider/potential spy) are squeezing a Black detainee in a sterile interrogation room. They have a "bigger goal": preventing an all-out gang war. But they don’t share that goal with him.

Instead, they weaponize his family. They threaten to seize and sell his mother’s home, leaving his family to live "in a shopping cart." In a city like Chicago, with its deep scars of segregation and predatory gentrification, everyone in that room (and in the audience) knows exactly what that threat means. It’s not just about a house; it’s about the total removal of a family from their community.

Earlier, we saw the home. The police had busted in, and the living room—the space for gathering and memory—was riddled with bullet holes from a shootout. In the middle of it, the mother holds her younger child, soothing them with back rubs while lying to the police to protect her older son.

The takeaway? To the police, that home is a chess piece in a "greater good" strategy. To the mother, it is a sanctuary under fire.

The Guidelines: A Framework for the “Wild”

I am, though, grappling with what these guidelines mean in the “wild.” In my work, family homes are always impacted by the application of various ethical frameworks used by the parties involved—and often, those frameworks aren’t designed to talk to one another.

The Ethical Engagement in Heirs’ Property Work guide was created to stop the "living in a shopping cart" threats and the bullet holes in the living room before they start. Here are the highlights of what the guidance framework actually demands from us:

Center the Family, Not the Transaction: Professionals are encouraged to look beyond the immediate "deal" and consider the multi-generational stability of the family. In our widower example, this means the Realtor’s "fiduciary duty" shouldn't be just a race for a commission, but a duty to ensure the resident isn't displaced.

Interdisciplinary Transparency: Because heirs' property sits at the intersection of law, real estate, and social work, the framework calls for "active transparency." If the police or the developers have a "bigger goal" (like a gang war or a new subdivision), ethical engagement requires that the family not be left in the dark.

Acknowledge the Power Imbalance: The guidelines recognize that land-rich, cash-poor families often have the "least capacity" but the "greatest need." A truly ethical framework requires professionals to level the playing field—by providing data and time so families can make decisions from a place of power, not in panic.

Cultural & Historical Competence: You can’t work in a city like Chicago or a suburbanizing farming town without acknowledging the history of segregation and displacement. The guidelines push us to recognize that for these families, we aren't just moving dirt; we are handling a legacy.

The Case Study: The 1-Acre Dilemma

(Imagine the percussive heartbeat and high-contrast grain...) DUN-DUN.

The Scene: A 1-acre lot abutting a critical tributary. To the left and right, similar heirs' property parcels have already been razed and redeveloped into suburban townhomes, causing massive environmental runoff.

The Characters:

  • The Resident: A baby-boomer widower (the step-father) on a fixed income. He’s in the "living room," just trying to survive.

  • The Sellers: The step-children, who have already signed a contract with a Realtor to list the home.

  • The Squeeze: A buyer is waiting with cash. The Realtor is pushing for a quick close. The Environmentalist is trying to block the sale to protect the river.

Like the interrogation room in Chicago PD, everyone here has a "bigger goal." But if the "shopping cart" threat becomes real for the widower—who is land rich but cash poor—who is the system actually serving? To the step-children, it's an asset. To the realtor, it's a commission. To the widower, it is his home.

Where I Stand: The Mavis Framework

This is where I find my footing. My ethical framework wasn’t born in a Fed boardroom; it was forged as a Scorpio middle child. I was parentalized out of necessity—I became the mediator and the "fixer" before I was even out of grade school.

I found community mediation at a young age, and it taught me that justice is what happens when we level the playing field. Today, as a techpreneur and data worker, I am seeking that same justice in the built and natural environment. I believe the family in the bullet-riddled living room deserves the same "intel" and protection as the developer in the boardroom.

In other words, I believe we all should get to eat. My framework is evolving, but it is strengthening because it has to. In a decade as chaotic as this last one, we don't need dry ethics—we need ethics with teeth.

What’s your "Living Room" story?

We’re all operating inside different ethical universes. Sometimes we’re the mother protecting the sanctuary; sometimes we’re the professional chasing a bigger goal.

I want to hear from you: Have you ever felt like your home or your work was being treated like a chess piece? How do you navigate the "shopping cart" threats in your own world?

With grit and care,

Mavis Gragg

Founder & CEO, HeirShares

Reply

Avatar

or to participate